In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Moderator: Scott Waters
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Could be another "Known from a single specimen" kind or herp or "Last recorded in 1985" or even "Only 130 exist in the wild now" herp. Lets see what you decide...
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Good idea for a thread but the question seems a bit ambiguous as stated. What do you mean by "your rarest"? I would interpret this most literally to mean one that I own, but that's obviously not your intent. Next to that I would guess you mean, "what's the rarest herp I've found" ...but then I also doubt if that's what you mean. ...So, I assume you just mean what is tha rarest herp in my opinion?
So, I would rule out anything not documented for an agreed upon period of time. Then I would prioritize those which are presumed extant, but for which only one specimen has ever been documented. So, for that there are likely several or more. But, some of those are only undocumented due to lack of coverage of appropriate habitat within range due to whatever circumstances.
I believe at least one of the Mexican long-tailed rattlesnakes would fit the "only one ever documented in accessible habitat" ...but I'm sure there are many others.
There is another consideration somewhat different. What about a species that is not difficult to find but exists only in limited numbers within one population, especially if that population is deemed at risk. The Tuatara would be a good candidate in the regard as would be the Solomon Island Skink(s).
Anyway, I haven't given this too much thought and I'm probably missing some good question/categorizations etc.
Somehow I think this one could take off. There are so many great minds here and anyway you slice it, great topic
So, I would rule out anything not documented for an agreed upon period of time. Then I would prioritize those which are presumed extant, but for which only one specimen has ever been documented. So, for that there are likely several or more. But, some of those are only undocumented due to lack of coverage of appropriate habitat within range due to whatever circumstances.
I believe at least one of the Mexican long-tailed rattlesnakes would fit the "only one ever documented in accessible habitat" ...but I'm sure there are many others.
There is another consideration somewhat different. What about a species that is not difficult to find but exists only in limited numbers within one population, especially if that population is deemed at risk. The Tuatara would be a good candidate in the regard as would be the Solomon Island Skink(s).
Anyway, I haven't given this too much thought and I'm probably missing some good question/categorizations etc.
Somehow I think this one could take off. There are so many great minds here and anyway you slice it, great topic
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
monklet wrote:Good idea for a thread but the question seems a bit ambiguous as stated. What do you mean by "your rarest"? I would interpret this most literally to mean one that I own, but that's obviously not your intent. Next to that I would guess you mean, "what's the rarest herp I've found" ...but then I also doubt if that's what you mean. ...So, I assume you just mean what is tha rarest herp in my opinion?
So, I would rule out anything not documented for an agreed upon period of time. Then I would prioritize those which are presumed extant, but for which only one specimen has ever been documented. So, for that there are likely several or more. But, some of those are only undocumented due to lack of coverage of appropriate habitat within range due to whatever circumstances.
I believe at least one of the Mexican long-tailed rattlesnakes would fit the "only one ever documented in accessible habitat" ...but I'm sure there are many others.
There is another consideration somewhat different. What about a species that is not difficult to find but exists only in limited numbers within one population, especially if that population is deemed at risk. The Tuatara would be a good candidate in the regard as would be the Solomon Island Skink(s).
Anyway, I haven't given this too much thought and I'm probably missing some good question/categorizations etc.
Somehow I think this one could take off. There are so many great minds here and anyway you slice it, great topic
Thanks, and sorry for the confusion . Spread the word, maybe it'll go on the board line or something? And what i was going for is spot on in what you said. Long-Tails aren't the only rare species out there. Plenty of other species are known from a single specimen.
- The Real Snake Man
- Posts: 405
- Joined: June 12th, 2010, 4:08 pm
- Location: Pasadena, CA or Mission, TX
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
T. rex. Once a dynamic part of the American landscape, they are now widely believed to be extinct. Finding one of those would be quite the herpetological achievement.
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
lol niceThe Real Snake Man wrote:T. rex. Once a dynamic part of the American landscape, they are now widely believed to be extinct. Finding one of those would be quite the herpetological achievement.
- The Real Snake Man
- Posts: 405
- Joined: June 12th, 2010, 4:08 pm
- Location: Pasadena, CA or Mission, TX
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
But in all seriousness, this question would probably be better stated as "What is the rarest herp in your area?" Simply asking for general opinions of the rarest taxon of herpetofauna will produce varied answers as monklet said above. As far as the rarest in the U.S. go, it would probably have to be either Eurycea robusta (the Blanco Blind Salamander, known from four specimens collected in 1951, and not seen since) or the Farancia erytrogramma seminola (South Florida Rainbow Snake, we all know the story).
-
- Posts: 1165
- Joined: June 7th, 2010, 7:25 am
- Location: Mobile, AL
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
There's some sort of Plethodon sp. salamander that's only known from one county in Mississippi, and is only known from a few specimens (and is probably now extinct).
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Nice! But outside the US and Mexico there are even more rare species. Lets see some more hands.Coluber Constrictor wrote:There's some sort of Plethodon sp. salamander that's only known from one county in Mississippi, and is only known from a few specimens (and is probably now extinct).
For Example- Cercophis auranus
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Either a Copperbelly Water Snake (Nerodia erythrogaster neglecta) with its small range of disjunct populations or Spot-tailed Earless Lizard (Holbrookia lacerata), a county record.
-
- Posts: 1165
- Joined: June 7th, 2010, 7:25 am
- Location: Mobile, AL
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Oh, you mean there rarest I've seen personally? That would be the Black Pine Snake:
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
That Black Pine is somewhat enviable
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
I interpret this as being the rarest herp that I have found/seen in the field.
I guess mine would have to be the Ricords Iguana (Cyclura ricordi), not difficult to see in the 1 area I saw it in but i would still classify it as a rare herp. Not least of all because it is so geographically restricted and is only found on a small portion of the island that the Dominican Republic and Haiti share. Population trends are decreasing and its listed as critically endangered.
Some more facts from the IUCN redlist page:
I guess mine would have to be the Ricords Iguana (Cyclura ricordi), not difficult to see in the 1 area I saw it in but i would still classify it as a rare herp. Not least of all because it is so geographically restricted and is only found on a small portion of the island that the Dominican Republic and Haiti share. Population trends are decreasing and its listed as critically endangered.
Some more facts from the IUCN redlist page:
I suppose the next rarest herp I have encountered is the Green Sea turtle (Chelonia mydas) which is listed as endangered but its not rare or hard to see in my experience so I wont post any photos.a current population estimate of 2,000 to 4,000 ....
Ricord’s iguanas are quite specialized. Several key environmental factors, including soil depth and texture, landform, bedrock parental material, and climate seem to determine their presence. Ricord’s iguanas inhabit the most arid regions of the Dominican Republic, where the climate is highly seasonal.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
The rarest herp I have ever found would probably be the California Mountain Kingsnake(Lampropeltis zonata). These are so rare the California Fish and Game Department has declared a bag/possesion limit of one.
- The Real Snake Man
- Posts: 405
- Joined: June 12th, 2010, 4:08 pm
- Location: Pasadena, CA or Mission, TX
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Is that a mugitus? Wow!
- ThatFrogGuy
- Posts: 744
- Joined: April 15th, 2011, 1:29 pm
- Location: Southern Indiana
- Contact:
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Plethodon ainsworthiColuber Constrictor wrote:There's some sort of Plethodon sp. salamander that's only known from one county in Mississippi, and is only known from a few specimens (and is probably now extinct).
Mine's not as much rare as it is secretive, but they have been declining in the area where it was found.
Eastern Tiger Salamander (Ambystoma tigrinum) by Zach Truelock, on Flickr
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Back in 1998 I saw a single Olm (Proteus anguinus). Crazy looking amphibian thing that lives only in 1 or 2 caves in Croatia.
Dave S.
Dave S.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
NO NOOOOOO Not this again!monklet wrote:Good idea for a thread but the question seems a bit ambiguous as stated. What do you mean by "your rarest"?
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
That's actually funny since these are invasives out here in California since they had been sold for bass (more invasives) bait.ThatFrogGuy wrote:Plethodon ainsworthiColuber Constrictor wrote:There's some sort of Plethodon sp. salamander that's only known from one county in Mississippi, and is only known from a few specimens (and is probably now extinct).
Mine's not as much rare as it is secretive, but they have been declining in the area where it was found.
Eastern Tiger Salamander (Ambystoma tigrinum) by Zach Truelock, on Flickr
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
There are a ton of examples here. I know salamanders, which have their fair share of restricted ranges and specific needs. I heard someone say that Van Dyke's (Plethodon vandykei) is one of the rarest vertebrates we have in N America. Don't know how much that holds up.
I do like Bolitoglossa jacksoni in my opinion, but it sure isn't the only one.
-Brad
I do like Bolitoglossa jacksoni in my opinion, but it sure isn't the only one.
-Brad
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
5 or so crocodylus acutus i found in one day in january of this year.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
The rarest herps I've seen have been northcentral FL's short-tailed snake (which I guess is Lampropeltis extenuatum these days)...
... and a few of the paedomorphic cave/spring Eurycea spp. of central TX. (I'll take a look at another computer later and see if I can find some pictures to share, though if I do they were likely taken for me rather than by me, while I was working with them - so maybe I should just ask Andy to chime in?... He's got way more experience with them than I do, anyway.)
Gerry
... and a few of the paedomorphic cave/spring Eurycea spp. of central TX. (I'll take a look at another computer later and see if I can find some pictures to share, though if I do they were likely taken for me rather than by me, while I was working with them - so maybe I should just ask Andy to chime in?... He's got way more experience with them than I do, anyway.)
Gerry
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Rare isn't really the best term. It implies something that exists in exceptionally low quantities, and is hard to come by. I can think of no herp in my region for which this applies, other than the Louisiana Pine Snake. I've never found one of those, so I really can't say much about them.
In Texas, the timber rattlesnake can be an extremely difficult find, unless you know where to look. Even if you do, finding them in habitat is difficult, and with road cruising you're much more likely to find a dead one than a live one (2 out of 16 were alive this year).
Here's a photo:
Crotalus horridus (Timber Rattlesnake) by Kyle L.E., on Flickr
Additionally, the tan racer is a difficult to find subspecies for many folks, and one that remains unchecked on a lot of life lists. I find them fairly easy to find, but many have considered them rare:
Coluber constrictor etheridgei (Tan Racer) by Kyle L.E., on Flickr
In Texas, the timber rattlesnake can be an extremely difficult find, unless you know where to look. Even if you do, finding them in habitat is difficult, and with road cruising you're much more likely to find a dead one than a live one (2 out of 16 were alive this year).
Here's a photo:
Crotalus horridus (Timber Rattlesnake) by Kyle L.E., on Flickr
Additionally, the tan racer is a difficult to find subspecies for many folks, and one that remains unchecked on a lot of life lists. I find them fairly easy to find, but many have considered them rare:
Coluber constrictor etheridgei (Tan Racer) by Kyle L.E., on Flickr
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
This guy, because I've been trying for ages and still have no idea what he is!!!! Some kind of Cnemaspis I think. Found on the walls and in the cracks of this rocky/boulder area in the Rain-forested hills of Trang. They are always there, day and night but are easier to catch at night with an LED flashlight. Usually they look more green.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Ive always wanted to find a shorty. I feel better knowing you succeeded in finding one.gbin wrote:The rarest herps I've seen have been northcentral FL's short-tailed snake (which I guess is Lampropeltis extenuatum these days)...
... and a few of the paedomorphic cave/spring Eurycea spp. of central TX. (I'll take a look at another computer later and see if I can find some pictures to share, though if I do they were likely taken for me rather than by me, while I was working with them - so maybe I should just ask Andy to chime in?... He's got way more experience with them than I do, anyway.)
Gerry
- Bryan Hamilton
- Posts: 1234
- Joined: June 10th, 2010, 9:49 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Diadophis in Nevada. Extremely secretive and spottily distributed, which to me equals rare.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
It's a word that one needs to be careful with, all right. I always simply read it as "rarely encountered" and keep in mind that the reasons for that can vary.Soopaman wrote:Rare isn't really the best term. It implies something that exists in exceptionally low quantities, and is hard to come by...
Thanks! I was actually out at one of my favorite places for scarlet kings that afternoon, searching for them by slowly hiking along and scanning for any that might be active in the leaf litter on the forest floor. I suppose some folks might laugh at such an idea, but I've found a few of them that way; as with pretty much any species, you just have to get to know your quarry and tailor your hunting methods to fit. I threw a few visual neurons when I encountered that short-tail, instead! It's the only one I ever found, though I've since had a couple of people tell me that they're really not that tough to find within their very limited range.dery wrote:Ive always wanted to find a shorty. I feel better knowing you succeeded in finding one.
Gerry
- Martti Niskanen
- Posts: 363
- Joined: June 11th, 2010, 11:19 am
- Location: Helsinki, Finland
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Rarest I've seen was a Proteus anguinus.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Finnaly a European sallie on FHF.Thank god
- Andy Avram
- Posts: 897
- Joined: June 7th, 2010, 10:37 am
- Location: NE Ohio
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
They are found naturally in a limited range that includes parts of Italy, Slovenia, Croatia and Bosnia. Introduced into a couple other locations. I think they are more readily viewed though in only 1 or 2 caves. Regardless, a very cool find. If I would have gone to Italy this year I would have considered trying for them.Dave S wrote:Back in 1998 I saw a single Olm (Proteus anguinus). Crazy looking amphibian thing that lives only in 1 or 2 caves in Croatia.
Dave S.
Many, many, many European salamanders have been posted on FHF over the years. In fact, I posted a Fire Salamander and Alpine Newt I found in Germany, just this past June. I believe one of the members here has seen all but a handful of the European herps and has posted many of them. A search should bring up some of these posts.dery wrote:Finnaly a European sallie on FHF.Thank god
As for my rarest herps seen (which I think is a much better topic thread, then a general "what's the rarest", would probably be Eastern Hellbender or Eastern Massasauga.
Andy
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Thanks gerry. I feel lucky now.gbin wrote:It's a word that one needs to be careful with, all right. I always simply read it as "rarely encountered" and keep in mind that the reasons for that can vary.Soopaman wrote:Rare isn't really the best term. It implies something that exists in exceptionally low quantities, and is hard to come by...
Thanks! I was actually out at one of my favorite places for scarlet kings that afternoon, searching for them by slowly hiking along and scanning for any that might be active in the leaf litter on the forest floor. I suppose some folks might laugh at such an idea, but I've found a few of them that way; as with pretty much any species, you just have to get to know your quarry and tailor your hunting methods to fit. I threw a few visual neurons when I encountered that short-tail, instead! It's the only one I ever found, though I've since had a couple of people tell me that they're really not that tough to find within their very limited range.dery wrote:Ive always wanted to find a shorty. I feel better knowing you succeeded in finding one.
Gerry
-
- Posts: 174
- Joined: August 4th, 2010, 8:07 am
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
I've heard these are extremely rare in the northeast. Felt good to finally add it to the lifelist.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Yep. Just never saw one for myself on here as far as sallies go.Andy Avram wrote:They are found naturally in a limited range that includes parts of Italy, Slovenia, Croatia and Bosnia. Introduced into a couple other locations. I think they are more readily viewed though in only 1 or 2 caves. Regardless, a very cool find. If I would have gone to Italy this year I would have considered trying for them.Dave S wrote:Back in 1998 I saw a single Olm (Proteus anguinus). Crazy looking amphibian thing that lives only in 1 or 2 caves in Croatia.
Dave S.
Many, many, many European salamanders have been posted on FHF over the years. In fact, I posted a Fire Salamander and Alpine Newt I found in Germany, just this past June. I believe one of the members here has seen all but a handful of the European herps and has posted many of them. A search should bring up some of these posts.dery wrote:Finnaly a European sallie on FHF.Thank god
As for my rarest herps seen (which I think is a much better topic thread, then a general "what's the rarest", would probably be Eastern Hellbender or Eastern Massasauga.
Andy
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Brendan Murray wrote:I've heard these are extremely rare in the northeast. Felt good to finally add it to the lifelist.
nice.
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
How bout stuff that you know is extremely rare (that you haven't found)
Example: Crotalus lannomi
Lets name some out!
Example: Crotalus lannomi
Lets name some out!
- Andy Avram
- Posts: 897
- Joined: June 7th, 2010, 10:37 am
- Location: NE Ohio
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Not that it makes that snake any less rare, but it was rediscovered a few years ago when 5 were captured in Mexico, by people that do or at least used to regularly post on this forum.intermedius wrote:How bout stuff that you know is extremely rare (that you haven't found)
Example: Crotalus lannomi
Lets name some out!
http://www.crotalus.com/Crotalus_lannom ... covery.pdf
- intermedius
- Posts: 481
- Joined: March 22nd, 2012, 7:19 pm
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Heard about it, just as a sample. And glad it got rediscovered. Just putting an example out.Andy Avram wrote:Not that it makes that snake any less rare, but it was rediscovered a few years ago when 5 were captured in Mexico, by people that do or at least used to regularly post on this forum.intermedius wrote:How bout stuff that you know is extremely rare (that you haven't found)
Example: Crotalus lannomi
Lets name some out!
http://www.crotalus.com/Crotalus_lannom ... covery.pdf
Another Example: Atelopus sanjosei
- Chris Smith
- Posts: 2291
- Joined: June 7th, 2010, 9:13 pm
- Location: Minnesota
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Incilius periglenes
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Rafetus swinhoei
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
Lampropeltis catalinensis, the Santa Catalina Island kingsnake has to be one of the rarest if not THE rarest snake in the world.
Known by one specimen.
Hundreds of herpers have gone there to look for it and nobody has found one in over 50 years.
Known by one specimen.
Hundreds of herpers have gone there to look for it and nobody has found one in over 50 years.
Re: In your opinion, whats your rarest reptile or amphibian?
gbin wrote:The rarest herps I've seen have been northcentral FL's short-tailed snake (which I guess is Lampropeltis extenuatum these days)...
... and a few of the paedomorphic cave/spring Eurycea spp. of central TX. (I'll take a look at another computer later and see if I can find some pictures to share, though if I do they were likely taken for me rather than by me, while I was working with them - so maybe I should just ask Andy to chime in?... He's got way more experience with them than I do, anyway.)
Gerry